• Ir al contenido principal
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Ir a la barra lateral primaria
  • Clases y conferencias
  • Sobre mí

Emprender a golpes

Blog personal de Miguel Arias sobre emprendedores, startups, inversiones, ecosistemas y tecnología

  • emprendedores
  • personal
  • como vender una startup
  • ilvp
  • poeta bajo tierra

Rethinking the corporate accelerator model

julio 6, 2020 por Miguel Arias Dejar un comentario

Recently, I participated in a very interesting discussion organized by our friends at Mind the Bridge with many other open innovation responsibles of global corporations.

The discussion I joined was around a new potential model for corporate accelerators, which is a topic I have strong opinions about ;). 

As Marco Marinucci mentioned in his opening statement, only 19% of corporations have no accelerator activities at all, but there is a decreasing interest in traditional acceleration programs.

In this article, Steve Blank states how «incubators and accelerators started popping up into every large company. We have created a ton of innovation theater, but I’m not sure we moved the needle on increasing revenue and profit in the line with all those investments».

Over the last years, we have taken many steps in Wayra to evolve from the temptations of the Innovation theater into providing meaningful tangible results. Moving from our previous 11 Academies in Europe and Latam centered around yearly batches and wide ecosystem support, to our current network of 7 regional Hubs aimed for more mature startups, and lately towards our on going plan of transforming our Hubs into Wayra Labs, where technologies & APIfied platforms are exposed and startups products are showcased for our customers, with space for co-creation and prototyping.

We are very much aligned with the vision presented by Mind the Bridge on the accelerators evolving towards Hybrid models: with blurry boundaries between physical and virtual worlds, stage agnostic, very open to external partners (VCs, universities, corporations, public bodies) and with different flavors depending on regions, business needs and strengths of the local ecosystem.

HOW TO STEP-UP IN MATURITY OF STARTUPS?

In order to move the needle of the corporate P&L, product market fit is key. And you cannot dismiss the relative size of the Elephant and the gazelle, hence if you want to shoot for opportunities over €50 million revenues to start with, understanding the total addressable market of your open innovation efforts is very relevant.

If you are really successful and you become the main reselling channel for your whole startup portfolio and represent, let’s say, 30% of their revenues (which is already a lot), then, in order to achieve a relevant aggregated number for your corporation: i.e over 250 Million euros for a company like Telefonica, (which would still be less than 5% of our B2B business), that means you will need the aggregated revenues from all your portfolio to be around 850M euros. And if your portfolio size is around 300-400 active startups, then their average revenues need to be on the range of 2-3 Millions euros por startup.

The corollary of this theory implies that if you work with early stage startups making yearly revenues of around €200-500K, it will never work out for you.

You may need to be stage agnostic and add some startups making over €5M or €10-15M in the series A-B space to your open innovation activities. And you also will need to design a mix between a venture capital and a venture client model, where investments are not the first step but the consequence of achieving relevant business development. 

And you need to be very clear about the value proposition for the startups, moving from just smart capital into market & tech  validation, customer access and expansion to other geographies with your brand and network as anchor partner. 

ORGANIZATION: BATCH VS. CHALLENGE DRIVEN

My bet is definitely on a sniper, targeted approach, where you add into your programs any startup which fits your needs with a 365 days a year scouting effort.

But you can spice this up, adding specific open challenges for the ecosystem, where you call out for innovators on very concrete pains or areas of interest. And the more you can add more relevant logos to the challenge the better; the quality of our joint challenges with NSCS, Novartis or RENFE around topics with strong personality, is significantly higher than our solo efforts.

And those key partners will also help you cover some of the OPEX of your initiatives and infrastructure, ensuring the model becomes more sustainable, which leads me to the next question:

ARE IN-HOUSE ACCELERATORS SUSTAINABLE IN THE LONG RUN?

If you try to just balance your OPEX against the return of the investment, it will be pretty hard to get your numbers in black.

An in-house corporate accelerator costs per year, counting office space, headcount, events budget, mentorships or external consultants, travel, scouting expenses.. will add up to a budget of around 1 million euros (heavily dependant on localization of course)

If you invest 2 million euros a year in CAPEX and you finally deliver a 2x cash on cash over 5 years (which would mean you are on the 10% best performance decile). Then you are giving back to your corporate controllers: 20 million euros – 10 million cash back= a 10 million ROI (not counting taxes or fees).

But it will take at least 10 years to get the money back (even more so if you invest very early on) hence you are also spending 10 millions in OPEX over the period, to keep your accelerator up and running. Thus, the odds are you will most likely lose money if you just count on the portfolio returns to cover your expenses.

But there are other returns on the investment besides comparing the portfolio financial metrics, like, what are the induced revenues you generate in the business units, which is the main reason you should have started your open innovation activities in the first place, or what business opportunities do you anchor through the innovations coming from the accelerators. How many revenues can you add by segmenting the startups as a high growth customer group?. And what is the value of the cultural shift you are fostering?.

There is this ripple effect on corporate innovation besides just the new revenue streams or operational efficiency savings, which goes way further, enabling Tech discovery, cultural change, high level institutional and corporate relations, etc.

ARE COMPANY BUILDERS & STARTUP STUDIOS AN ALTERNATIVE?

I am a big proponent of Venture Builders for corporates, but only if you have a truly unfair competitive differentiator for a specific business idea, which is also sustainable over time.

With the Venture Builder, you are actually creating sort of a Frankenstein, mixing corporate ideas, corporate go-to-market channels and pseudo-entrepreneurial managers. If you want to beat your agile startup competitors in the space,  you will need a unique unfair advantage. It can be access to assets which are not open to the public (data, infrastructure, IP..) or a key insight about a potential future thanks to customer research etc

And it is critical to be able to source and validate the ideas internally and furthermore, avoid mild yeses when you push the project forward in the different committees. You will need very strong internal sponsorship and accountability.

Try to avoid the backing corporate becoming your first customer in the new companies you build. Actually try to get some middle sized more flexible companies to be your guinea pigs, and after that you can try to get scale with the Bigger mother company.

And use the same scouting and company’s needs sourcing interface for the Venture Builder and the rest of the investment vehicles, to avoid duplicities and misaligned efforts. If you have a strong sponsor, a clearly defined need with a strong unique competitive advantage and you don’t find any startup solving those really huge pains, then it is probably worth building it.

Coordination is critical there!.

Comparte este artículo:

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Email WhatsApp

Archivado en:emprendedores, open innovation Etiquetado con:corporate accelerator, corporates, early stage, mind the bridge, open innovation, scaling up, startups, telefonica, venture builders, venture client, wayra

Acerca de Miguel Arias

He is an active Business Angel investing in Internet based start-ups in Spain. He founded Chamberi Valley, the leading network of consolidated tech entrepreneurs in Madrid.

Interacciones con los lectores

Deja una respuesta Cancelar la respuesta

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *

Barra lateral primaria

Redes sociales

  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Miguel AriasFollow

Miguel Arias
Retweet on TwitterMiguel Arias Retweeted
TE_pymesTelefónica Empresas pymes@TE_pymes·
3h

Telefónica pone su red a disposición de las #startups para servicios de #5G y #EdgeComputing

@mike_arias, Dir. de Emprendimiento en Telefónica:

"Estas nuevas tecnologías con tanto potencial serán clave en el desarrollo de aplicaciones innovadoras para digitalizar la sociedad”

Reply on Twitter 1352639660820844549Retweet on Twitter 13526396608208445492Like on Twitter 13526396608208445492Twitter 1352639660820844549
mike_ariasMiguel Arias@mike_arias·
9h

Interesante discusión

J@joaquinmencia

Me pasa lo opuesto. ¿Soy el raro?

Déjame mi tiempo y mi espacio.

Idem para zooms y reuniones. Todo lo que pueda ser asíncrono, que sea asíncrono. Y la mitad de lo que necesitas inmediatamente es probable que pueda esperar. https://twitter.com/mike_arias/status/1352549514872320000

Reply on Twitter 1352557790607323136Retweet on Twitter 1352557790607323136Like on Twitter 13525577906073231362Twitter 1352557790607323136
Retweet on TwitterMiguel Arias Retweeted
oriollloretOriol Lloret@oriollloret·
10h

Ya podéis disfrutar en MOVISTAR de uno de los productos que hemos estado creando en Telefonica Core Innovation los últimos meses: Movistar Campus. Una Plataforma de ‘edutainment’ con los mejores partners de contenidos, como Domestika o Podimo https://youtu.be/vKxwLCzt5qA

Reply on Twitter 1352545567558283267Retweet on Twitter 13525455675582832672Like on Twitter 135254556755828326714Twitter 1352545567558283267
mike_ariasMiguel Arias@mike_arias·
9h

Llama más veces. Si quieres una respuesta rápida, llama. Si quieres discutir un tema, llama. Todo hilo de correos que podría ser una llamada, debería ser una llamada. Y no toda llamada debe ser un zoom. #deathbyemail

Reply on Twitter 1352549514872320000Retweet on Twitter 135254951487232000035Like on Twitter 1352549514872320000224Twitter 1352549514872320000
mike_ariasMiguel Arias@mike_arias·
10h

Escribe más veces, de cualquier cosa, con menos texto. Utiliza el lenguaje para explicar qué quieres, para aclarar tus ideas, para desgranar detalles, pero ve al grano. Siempre. #deathbypowerpoint

Reply on Twitter 1352541791061467137Retweet on Twitter 13525417910614671372Like on Twitter 135254179106146713736Twitter 1352541791061467137
Cargar más...

Busca temas de interés

adquisición arrola Business Angel business angels carto cartodb chamberi valley como vender una startup due diligence ecosistema ecosistema emprendedor elevator pitch emprendedor emprendedores emprender emprender a golpes equipo gary stewart ie business school imaste innovación inversores ivlp iñaki arrola ley de emprendedores M&A madrid maria fanjul mercado miguel arias multivent on24 open innovation personal seedrocket silicon valley startup startups talento telefonica ticketea twitter venture lab vitamina k wayra

Blogs que leo

Angel Arias

Poeta Bajo Tierra

Un fonendo en Villamocos

François Derbaix

Iñaki Arrola

Javier Andrés

Al Socaire

Mark Suster

Planeta Huevo

Marek Fodor

Mis proyectos

Wayra
Carto
Chamberi Valley
Imaste
IE Business School

Inversor – Advisor

Marfeel
Reallylatebooking
Reclamador.es
Graphext
Dada Company
Vizzuality
Cream E-sports

 

Entradas recientes

  • Los posts más leídos de 2020 en Emprenderagolpes
  • A por un 2021 distinto
  • Mis predicciones para 2021
  • Dancing with Gazelles
  • Nace Wayra X, disruption first

Ultimos comentarios

  • Boletín No. 83 – Consciencia en Red en 10 cosas que he aprendido después de invertir en 50 startups seed
  • item255303331 en 6 Cosas que he aprendido de mi padre y 1 que aprendí yo solo
  • ¿Cómo evuluciona el roll de Ceo cuando evoluciona a ScaleUp? – Coaching DSC en ¿Qué hace a un buen COO?
  • Los 14 sesgos mentales del emprendedor (o por qué no vemos el mundo tal como es) | El Blog de Javier Megias en Círculo virtuoso vs Círculo vicioso
  • ¿Cómo evoluciona el rol del CEO de una startup cuando se convierte en una scaleup? - Grouz - Todas las noticias y artículos sobre Startups y Emprendedores en España y en el Mundo en ¿Qué hace a un buen COO?

Emprender a Golpes © 2021 · Proud dad. Serial entrepreneur, hobbyist business angel and corporate translator